United fans debate keeper situation ahead of Derby Day

Andre Onana is close to a move to Trabzonspor on loan

We have been asking Manchester United fans for their opinion on this news and who should be keeper for this weekend's Manchester Derby and for the rest of the campaign.

Author | Olivia T

Could the match against Grimsby Town be Onana's last for the club?

This is what fans have been saying

Pat: I’m surprised Onana stayed first choice for as long as he did. The mistakes were there from the start, yet he kept his place against the judgement of fans and pundits alike. Lammens should be given the chance to show why he was brought in ahead of Emi Martínez and, ideally, establish himself as our long-term number one. That could be the foundation of a defence that badly needs stability.

Jamie: Letting Onana leave was the right decision. He never looked close to the standard required for the Premier League. Hopefully he does well in Turkey and a permanent move can be arranged next summer.

READ MORE | An encouraging transfer window for Manchester United?

Liam C: Onana looked a fine goalkeeper at Inter Milan, but two seasons on he has not adapted to the Premier League. It makes sense to let him continue his career elsewhere. For the derby against City, I would start Tom Heaton and give Lammens time to settle with his new team-mates in training.

Ali: If it were not such a big game on Sunday, I would throw in Lammens straight away. Instead, he might benefit from a couple of reserve matches before being asked to start. For this one, Bayindir should probably get the nod.

Bayindir playing in pre-season

Matty: Lammens should start the derby. He has not been called up by Belgium so will have had two weeks at Carrington to adjust. There are no cup ties to ease him in, and Bayindir has already shown he is unreliable.

Marcus: Our goalkeeping situation feels close to disastrous. I am not convinced by any of them, and constant rotation only creates uncertainty. We need to pick one and stay with him. At the moment, I am deeply concerned.